Five stars with real volume · November 2026 figures
Pizza places in New South Wales
- Pizza Places compared
- 873
- Google reviews
- 266,156
- Median rating
- 4.4
As of November 2026, the three pizza places in New South Wales rated 4.6 or better with the most Google reviews on Faultless Few are Mammas and Papas Ristorante and Pizzeria (4.8 from 2,186 Google reviews), Bella Brutta (4.6 from 1,915 Google reviews) and Pizza Bros (4.6 from 1,714 Google reviews).
Pizza places in New South Wales: the top 50
- 1
Mammas and Papas Ristorante and Pizzeria
from 2,186 Google reviews
40 Perouse Rd, Randwick NSW 2031
- 2
Bella Brutta
from 1,915 Google reviews
135 King St, Newtown NSW 2042
- 3
Pizza Bros
from 1,714 Google reviews
35 Erskineville Rd, Erskineville NSW 2043
- 4
Pocket Pizza Manly
from 1,337 Google reviews
- 5
Yalla Yalla Pizzeria
from 1,269 Google reviews
57 Helen St, Sefton NSW 2162
- 6
Sicilian Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria The Rocks
from 1,157 Google reviews
17 Playfair St, The Rocks NSW 2000
- 7
Lil Franky Pizzeria
from 1,148 Google reviews
703 Princes Hwy, Tempe NSW 2044
- 8
Da Orlando Pizzeria (Wollongong)
from 1,079 Google reviews
348 Keira St, Wollongong NSW 2500
- 9
Pizza Peddlers & BAR
from 1,047 Google reviews
Shop 3/46 Picnic Parade, Ettalong Beach NSW 2257
- 10
Pinocchio's Pizza Albion Park
from 1,014 Google reviews
148 Terry St, Albion Park NSW 2527
- 11
Epic Pizza
from 952 Google reviews
192 Enmore Rd, Enmore NSW 2042
- 12
My Mother's Cousin Bexley North
from 938 Google reviews
9 Shaw St, Bexley North NSW 2207
- 13
Dough Time Quakers Hill
from 856 Google reviews
3 Nirimba Dr, Quakers Hill NSW 2763
- 14
Wyoming Hungry Wolf's Pizza & Pasta
from 851 Google reviews
470 Pacific Hwy, Central Coast NSW 2250
- 15
Ta Ta Ta Pizza
from 830 Google reviews
10 Gray St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
- 16
Pizza Boccone
from 784 Google reviews
11 Llankelly Pl, Potts Point NSW 2011
- 17
La Panchina
from 775 Google reviews
Shop 3/496 Bourke St, Surry Hills NSW 2010
- 18
Pizza Hut Collaroy
from 759 Google reviews
Shop C/996 Pittwater Rd, Collaroy NSW 2097
- 19
Gerringong Pizza
from 747 Google reviews
1/121-123 Fern St, Gerringong NSW 2534
- 20
Lennox Pizza Bar and Kitchen
from 730 Google reviews
4/74 Ballina St, Lennox Head NSW 2478
- 21
The Hub Gourmet Pizza Bar Orange
from 728 Google reviews
- 22
Johnny Tapas
from 726 Google reviews
7 Mitchell St, Norah Head NSW 2263
- 23
Deluxe Gourmet Pizza Engadine
from 693 Google reviews
2 Waratah Rd, Engadine NSW 2233
- 24
Westwood
from 679 Google reviews
245 Australia St, Newtown NSW 2042
- 25
Joe's Pizza Parlour
from 663 Google reviews
207 Mann St, Central Coast NSW 2250
- 26
Maggie's Pizzeria
from 628 Google reviews
12 Mount Druitt Rd, Mount Druitt NSW 2770
- 27
Sorrento Pizzeria Empire Bay
from 611 Google reviews
1 Sorrento Rd, Central Coast NSW 2257
- 28
La Coppola
from 610 Google reviews
152 Redfern St, Redfern NSW 2016
- 29
Pizza Da Noi
from 593 Google reviews
Shop 4/198-206 St Johns Rd, Glebe NSW 2037
- 30
Minelli's Pizzeria & Cafe
from 564 Google reviews
Shop 2/40 Jersey Rd, Emerton NSW 2770
- 31
Crust Pizza Port Macquarie
from 553 Google reviews
Kmart, 23-41 Park St, Port Macquarie NSW 2444
- 32
Rene's Pizza Place Blacktown
from 548 Google reviews
Shop 1/1 Muru Way, Blacktown NSW 2148
- 33
Mt Lewis Pizzeria South Hurstville
from 542 Google reviews
797 King Georges Road, South Hurstville NSW 2221
- 34
Pizza on the Horsley
from 532 Google reviews
1/459 The Horsley Dr, Fairfield NSW 2165
- 35
Yummy Manoush
from 526 Google reviews
3/4 Minto Rd, Minto NSW 2566
- 36
Mars Pizza
from 523 Google reviews
76A Agincourt Rd, Marsfield NSW 2122
- 37
Donny's Pizza Abbotsford
from 507 Google reviews
547 Great N Rd, Abbotsford NSW 2046
- 38
Whistler Pizza Manly
from 483 Google reviews
- 39
Tasty Manoush and Pizza
from 476 Google reviews
159 Rooty Hill Rd S, Eastern Creek NSW 2766
- 40
Ciro's Pizza
from 474 Google reviews
1 Raymond Rd, Thirroul NSW 2515
- 41
Monterey Pizza Cafe
from 474 Google reviews
62 Scarborough St, Monterey NSW 2217
- 42
Pauly's Gourmet Kitchen
from 472 Google reviews
69 Dora St, Morisset NSW 2264
- 43
Otto Pizzeria Cafe
from 468 Google reviews
South City Shopping Centre, Shop 13/1-7 Tanda Pl, Glenfield Park NSW 2650
- 44
City Oltra
from 466 Google reviews
Shop 11/1 Eddy Ave, Haymarket NSW 2000
- 45
I Love Pizza Crows Nest
from 465 Google reviews
316 Pacific Hwy, Crows Nest NSW 2065
- 46
Ricks Pizzeria e Ristorante
from 459 Google reviews
Unit 8/8 Merriville Rd, Kellyville Ridge NSW 2155
- 47
Let's Eat Pizza
from 447 Google reviews
18 Anella Avenue, Castle Hill NSW 2154
- 48
BSP’ERIA Penshurst
from 444 Google reviews
129 Laycock Rd, Penshurst NSW 2222
- 49
Johnny's Pizza & Pasta
from 433 Google reviews
558B Pennant Hills Rd, West Pennant Hills NSW 2125
- 50
Young's Gourmet Pizzeria
from 427 Google reviews
54 Denman Parade, Normanhurst NSW 2076
Faultless Few compared 873 pizza places in New South Wales, with 266,156 Google reviews between them. Of these, 248 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.4 from a median of 207 reviews.
Of the pizza places compared, the most reviewed is Bondi Pizza, with 4,174 Google reviews at 4.4.
How this list is ranked
Only businesses rated 4.6 or better from at least 50 Google reviews are listed, ranked by how many reviews they have.
A rating can move quickly, and a business just under 4.6 or 50 reviews may be just as good.
Questions
- Which pizza places in New South Wales are rated 4.6 or better from at least 50 Google reviews?
- As of November 2026, the three pizza places in New South Wales rated 4.6 or better with the most Google reviews on Faultless Few are Mammas and Papas Ristorante and Pizzeria (4.8 from 2,186 Google reviews), Bella Brutta (4.6 from 1,915 Google reviews) and Pizza Bros (4.6 from 1,714 Google reviews).
- How does Faultless Few rank pizza places in New South Wales?
- Only businesses rated 4.6 or better from at least 50 Google reviews are listed, ranked by how many reviews they have. A rating can move quickly, and a business just under 4.6 or 50 reviews may be just as good.
- How many pizza places in New South Wales did Faultless Few compare?
- Faultless Few compared 873 pizza places in New South Wales, with 266,156 Google reviews between them. Of these, 248 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.4 from a median of 207 reviews.