Faultless Few

Five stars with real volume · November 2026 figures

Pizza places in Newcastle

Pizza Places compared
43
Google reviews
8,667
Median rating
4.4

As of November 2026, the three pizza places in Newcastle, NSW rated 4.6 or better with the most Google reviews on Faultless Few are Pauly's Gourmet Kitchen (4.7 from 472 Google reviews), 3 Sicilians Ristorante (4.8 from 408 Google reviews) and Harry's Gourmet Pizza (4.6 from 210 Google reviews).

Pizza places in Newcastle: the top 8

  1. 1

    Pauly's Gourmet Kitchen

    4.7from 472 Google reviews

    69 Dora St, Morisset NSW 2264

    Call

  2. 2

    3 Sicilians Ristorante

    4.8from 408 Google reviews

    Corner of Clyde &, 29 Douglas St, Stockton NSW 2295

    CallWebsite

  3. 3

    Harry's Gourmet Pizza

    4.6from 210 Google reviews

    263 Brunker Rd, Adamstown NSW 2289

    CallWebsite

  4. 4

    Bar Solè

    4.7from 178 Google reviews

    173 Maitland Rd, Tighes Hill NSW 2297

    CallWebsite

  5. 5

    Blue Moon Pizza

    4.8from 78 Google reviews

    Unit 4/267 Soldiers Point Rd, Salamander Bay NSW 2317

    CallWebsite

  6. 6

    Fermento Pizza Joint

    4.9from 70 Google reviews

    436 Maitland Rd, Mayfield West NSW 2304

    CallWebsite

  7. 7

    Pilgrim's Pizzas

    4.6from 69 Google reviews

    21 Main Rd, Boolaroo NSW 2284

    CallWebsite

  8. 8

    Just One More Pizza

    5.0from 53 Google reviews

    1470 Wine Country Dr, Rothbury NSW 2320

    Call

Faultless Few compared 43 pizza places in Newcastle, NSW, with 8,667 Google reviews between them. Of these, 8 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.4 from a median of 178 reviews.

Of the pizza places compared, the most reviewed is Ribs & Pizza on Glebe, with 561 Google reviews at 4.4.

How this list is ranked

Only businesses rated 4.6 or better from at least 50 Google reviews are listed, ranked by how many reviews they have.

A rating can move quickly, and a business just under 4.6 or 50 reviews may be just as good.

The whole method and its rules

Questions

Which pizza places in Newcastle, NSW are rated 4.6 or better from at least 50 Google reviews?
As of November 2026, the three pizza places in Newcastle, NSW rated 4.6 or better with the most Google reviews on Faultless Few are Pauly's Gourmet Kitchen (4.7 from 472 Google reviews), 3 Sicilians Ristorante (4.8 from 408 Google reviews) and Harry's Gourmet Pizza (4.6 from 210 Google reviews).
How does Faultless Few rank pizza places in Newcastle, NSW?
Only businesses rated 4.6 or better from at least 50 Google reviews are listed, ranked by how many reviews they have. A rating can move quickly, and a business just under 4.6 or 50 reviews may be just as good.
How many pizza places in Newcastle, NSW did Faultless Few compare?
Faultless Few compared 43 pizza places in Newcastle, NSW, with 8,667 Google reviews between them. Of these, 8 meet this list's method. The median rating is 4.4 from a median of 178 reviews.